Monday, February 16, 2009

Idaho Board of Environmental Quality Folds Under Industry Pressure

In a state that doesn't even have a single coal fired EGU, the Idaho Board of Environmental Quality caved in to an industry lead attack on its request for a voluntary program for mercury emission reductions. Idaho, a state that pushed hard to get neighboring Nevada to control mercury emissions from their gold mining operations, can't find the backbone internally to support a voluntary program. Seems sort of strange to me.

A reprint from an Idaho Statesman article quoting a post by blogger Rocky Barker follows;

In a cloud of uncertainty, the Idaho Board of Environmental Quality backed off its efforts to strengthen rules to regulate industries that emit mercury into the air.

The board voted down a motion Feb. 12 that would have asked industries to voluntarily (emphasis added) install the best available technology for removing mercury from their smokestacks under a well-coordinated lobbying effort by the Idaho Association of Industry and Commerce, the Idaho Council on Industry and Environment and Monsanto Corp., whose P4 phosphate plant in Caribou County in Southeast Idaho is the state's largest mercury source.

The industry groups rolled over the Idaho Conservation League, which had petitioned to get the board to regulate mercury in the state in an effort to combat the pollutant that accumulates in fish and can cause brain damage and learning disabilities in babies and young children. The ICL and its program manager Justin Hayes had successfully led the effort to get the state of Nevada to require gold mines in that neighboring state to restrict much higher mercury emissions after studies showed that winds were carrying the neurotoxin into Idaho and that at least one reservoir, Salmon Falls Creek south of Twin Falls, had high mercury levels.

Hayes had convinced federal and Nevada officials that their voluntary program was allowing miners to pump thousands of pounds of mercury into the air. Today, Nevada has one of the strongest mercury abatement programs for mines in the world.

But the case for regulation was not as clear in Idaho, and the industry groups were far more sophisticated about exploiting the uncertainty in the science.

They hired one of the world's top mercury pollution experts, Steve Lindberg, a retired environmental chemist from Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee. He has helped develop mercury rules for states and the EPA and has worked on both sides of the issue throughout his career.

He said in a report and a presentation to the board that the science linking a source like the P4 plant to high mercury levels in fish in nearby reservoirs was not yet clear enough. He raised questions about whether atmospheric mercury pollution was as serious a problem in the American West as it is in the East, where there is more rain and more wet deposition of the pollutant.

And he even raised doubts, based on yet unpublished research, that the high mercury levels in Salmon Falls Creek Reservoir were linked to the massive mercury pollution that had come from the mines in Nevada before they were regulated.

Previously, the board had heard from U.S. Environmental Protection Agency experts that models showed a source like the P4 plant could be linked to the elevated mercury levels in nearby lakes. But even Hayes acknowledged that science was not yet clear.

He urged the board to put in place regulations that would limit mercury pollution, especially in new sources. The current regulations are aimed at keeping mercury inhalation by workers and people near a plant low. But they allow a company to emit huge levels of mercury, as much as 100,000 pounds, which all agree would be harmful to the state's aquatic systems.

But the P4's emissions, at 600-700 pounds, are far below such numbers. They still are higher than coal-fired power plants. Its officials say they have erred on the high side of their estimates because EPA reporting requirements have high penalties for reporting below actual emissions.

And Monsanto says its scrubbers for other pollutants have reduced mercury emissions. It proposed that the state use water quality regulations to control mercury levels in lakes instead of air regulations.

"This confusion and uncertainty makes it hard for us to make rules," said Nick Purdy, a board member from Picabo.

So the state's flawed rules - even by Lindberg's opinion - stay in place for now.

It is situations like this where local industry groups fight a local regulation because they can shed doubt on its local effects that scream for Federal action. No one denies that mercury emissions, like the 600 - 700 pounds per year coming from the Monsanto plant are adding to the global problem of mercury emissions; they simply say our emissions aren't necessarily effecting our waters and thus our citizens, so we should not regulate them. Damn everybody downwind, and oh, by the way, let's get tough with everybody upwind of us and get them to regulate, but not us. What a joke.

19 comments:

Steve said...

There have been important developments in this story which should be linked in your column. See http://www.idahostatesman.com/102/story/841245.html

Anonymous said...

Hiya i'm fresh to this, I stumbled upon this forum I find It truly accessible & it has helped me alot. I should be able to give something back & support others like its helped me.

Cheers, See Ya Later.

Anonymous said...

Hello i am fresh here, I hit upon this site I find It amply accommodating & its helped me out a lot. I hope to contribute and assist other people like it has helped me.

Thank You, See Ya Later

Anonymous said...

Whats's Up im new on here, I came upon this site I have found It quite accessible & it's helped me alot. I hope to contribute & support other users like it has helped me.

Thank's, Catch You Around.

Anonymous said...

Greetings im fresh to this. I stumbled upon this chat board I have found It vastly useful & it's helped me a lot. I should be able to contribute & support other people like it has helped me.

Thanks Everyone, See You Around.

Anonymous said...

Sup im new to this. I came accross this message board I have found It amply useful & its helped me alot. I should be able to contribute & support other people like it has helped me.

Cheers, See You Around

Anonymous said...

Howdy im new on here, I stumbled upon this website I have found It very accessible & it's helped me a great deal. I should be able to give something back & help other people like its helped me.

Thank You, See Ya Around.

Anonymous said...

Hello i'm fresh to this, I came upon this message board I find It truly accommodating and it has helped me out tons. I should be able to contribute and support other people like it has helped me.

Thanks, See Ya Around.

Anonymous said...

Hi i'm new to this, I hit upon this forum I find It extremely helpful & it's helped me out alot. I should be able to give something back and support other people like its helped me.

Thank You, Catch You Later.

Anonymous said...

Heya i'm fresh to this. I came upon this message board I have found It extremely accommodating & it's helped me so much. I hope to contribute & support other users like its helped me.

Cheers all, Catch You Around.

Anonymous said...

Sup i am fresh here, I came accross this forum I have found It incredibly accessible and its helped me a great deal. I hope to contribute & support other people like its helped me.

Cheers, See Ya Around.

Anonymous said...

Whats's Up i am fresh here, I came upon this chat board I have found It absolutely accessible & its helped me tons. I should be able to contribute & aid others like its helped me.

Cheers all, See You Later.

Anonymous said...

Aloha i'm new on here. I hit upon this message board I find It vastly accessible and it has helped me out alot. I hope to contribute and assist other people like it has helped me.

Thank's, See You About.

Anonymous said...

Hey im new on here, I hit upon this website I find It very useful & it has helped me a lot. I should be able to give something back & support other users like its helped me.

Cheers, Catch You Around

Anonymous said...

Heya i am new here. I stumbled upon this board I find It absolutely useful & it has helped me tons. I hope to contribute and assist other people like its helped me.

Thank You, See You Around

Anonymous said...

you people are really good nice to be here [url=http://strollertxxw.co.cc/micralite-fastfold-liner-hampton-falls.html]micralite fastfold liner[/url]

Anonymous said...

This is really good forum i love it a lot [url=http://ykpmcooking.co.cc/golden-pond-kitchenaid-helpline.html]kitchenaid helpline[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://cookingvhiq.co.cc/scanpan+32cm+wok+cruzville.html]scanpan 32cm wok[/url] I like this forum :)

Anonymous said...

[url=http://ozclcooking.co.cc/hamilton+beach+33967+review+grove+center.html]hamilton beach 33967 review[/url] i will keep updating and this is excellent forum